When it comes to streaming platforms like Peacock, Hulu, and Paramount+, big titles often dominate the spotlight—think blockbuster hits, Emmy-winning dramas, and shows with major stars attached. But what about the hidden gems quietly tucked away in the libraries of these platforms? These are the underrated series that might not trend on social media but are every bit as binge-worthy, offering unique stories, fresh perspectives, and addictive storytelling.

The beauty of exploring underrated series is the thrill of discovery. These shows can feel more personal because not everyone has seen them. You become the person recommending a hidden gem to your friends, a curator of great content they might otherwise miss. Additionally, underrated shows often take creative risks, experiment with new formats, or focus on niche topics, making them stand out in a sea of familiar genres.

In this blog, we’ll highlight some of the best underrated series you can binge right now on Peacock, Hulu, and Paramount+. Each platform has its own flavor: Peacock offers quirky comedies and edgy dramas, Hulu blends original content with network favorites, and Paramount+ shines with crime dramas, sci-fi, and reboots done right. Whether you’re craving something funny, suspenseful, or thought-provoking, these hidden gems will keep you glued to your screen.

Peacock’s Hidden Gems: Quirky, Bold, and Surprisingly Addictive
 

Peacock might not always be the first streaming platform people think of, but its catalog is full of underrated series worth bingeing. Beyond well-known titles like The Office or Yellowstone, Peacock offers an impressive lineup of original content and overlooked series that push boundaries and deliver fresh storytelling.

One standout is “Girls5eva”, a witty comedy about a one-hit-wonder girl group from the ’90s trying to make a comeback in the present day. It’s a perfect blend of nostalgia and modern humor, filled with sharp writing and catchy songs that will stay in your head long after the credits roll. Despite critical acclaim, it hasn’t gotten the mainstream attention it deserves, making it an excellent candidate for your next binge-watch.

If you’re into dark comedies with an edge, “Poker Face” is another must-watch. Created by Rian Johnson (Knives Out), it stars Natasha Lyonne as a drifter with an uncanny ability to detect lies. Each episode functions like a standalone mystery, reminiscent of old-school detective shows but with a modern, quirky twist. It’s stylish, smart, and one of Peacock’s strongest original offerings.

For something completely different, “A.P. Bio” delivers a hilarious take on high school life. The show follows a disgraced Harvard philosophy professor who ends up teaching biology in his hometown, where he schemes to use his students for personal revenge. It’s weird, sharp, and laugh-out-loud funny, but it often gets overshadowed by bigger network comedies.

Peacock’s underrated series shine because they dare to be unconventional. They don’t always fit into a standard mold, but that’s what makes them so refreshing. If you’re looking to step outside the mainstream and discover shows that take creative risks, Peacock is well worth a deep dive.
 

Hulu’s Best Kept Secrets: Layered, Emotional, and Unexpectedly Brilliant
 

Hulu is often praised for big-name series like The Handmaid’s Tale or Only Murders in the Building, but beneath its star-studded hits lies a treasure trove of underrated series worth bingeing. These hidden gems explore everything from personal identity to dark comedy, and they often resonate deeply with viewers who stumble upon them.

Take “Ramy”, for example. This semi-autobiographical dramedy follows a young Muslim-American navigating life, faith, and identity in modern America. With sharp humor and heartfelt storytelling, it paints an authentic picture rarely seen on TV. While it’s critically acclaimed, many casual Hulu viewers overlook it, which makes it a perfect binge for those wanting something thought-provoking yet funny.

For fans of gritty drama, “Reprisal” is a stylish, revenge-fueled series that flew under the radar. Set in a world of gangsters, vintage cars, and noir-inspired visuals, it follows a woman seeking vengeance against her brother and his crew who wronged her. Despite being visually stunning and narratively bold, it never got the mainstream push it deserved, making it a true hidden gem for fans of dark thrillers.

Another underrated gem is “The Great”, a satirical take on the rise of Catherine the Great of Russia. While it has gained some recognition, it still doesn’t get the credit it deserves for its witty writing, eccentric tone, and brilliant performances by Elle Fanning and Nicholas Hoult. It’s not a typical period drama—it’s outrageous, clever, and endlessly entertaining.

What makes Hulu’s underrated series stand out is their emotional depth and layered storytelling. They often take a familiar genre—comedy, drama, period piece—and flip it on its head, offering something unexpected and memorable. For viewers willing to look past the big titles, Hulu’s hidden gems are rich with originality and deserve a binge-session spotlight.
 

Paramount+ Treasures: Crime, Sci-Fi, and Nostalgic Reboots Done Right
 

Paramount+ has been steadily growing its library, becoming a go-to platform for fans of crime dramas, sci-fi adventures, and nostalgic reboots. While its biggest hits like Star Trek: Discovery or 1883 grab attention, there are several underrated series worth bingeing that don’t get nearly enough love.

One standout is “Evil”, a supernatural procedural that blends horror, psychology, and faith. The series follows a psychologist, a priest-in-training, and a tech expert investigating strange cases that blur the line between science and the supernatural. It’s creepy, thought-provoking, and often surprisingly funny—a unique mix that deserves far more recognition than it gets.

Fans of political thrillers should check out “Madam Secretary”, which has found a second life on Paramount+. Though it originally aired on CBS, it’s an underrated gem in the political drama genre, with Téa Leoni delivering a standout performance as a Secretary of State balancing global crises with family life. It’s intelligent, inspiring, and feels more relevant than ever.

For those craving nostalgia with a modern twist, “iCarly (Reboot)” is a surprisingly charming revival of the beloved Nickelodeon classic. Unlike many reboots, this one successfully updates the story for both old fans and new audiences, tackling adult themes while still keeping the quirky humor intact. It hasn’t become a huge cultural moment, but it’s well worth a binge if you grew up with the original.

And let’s not forget “Why Women Kill”, a stylish anthology series that explores betrayal, marriage, and murder across different eras. With sharp writing and stunning visuals, it’s a binge-worthy gem that often gets overshadowed by bigger crime dramas.

Paramount+ excels at combining nostalgia with bold storytelling. Its underrated series often take familiar genres—crime, sci-fi, comedy—and twist them into something new and engaging. If you’re in the mood for shows that balance creativity with comfort, Paramount+ has plenty of treasures waiting to be discovered.