Islands With More Stories Than People: Mythic, Remote & Unforgettable

Some islands have postcard-perfect beaches. Others have luxury resorts. But then there are islands where the true treasure isn’t the view—it’s the stories. These are places where the population might be counted on your fingers, yet the myths, ghost tales, and historic sagas could fill libraries.

They’re scattered across the globe, often hard to reach and even harder to forget. On these islands, the landscape is more than scenery—it’s a living stage where centuries of folklore still echo in the waves, in the wind, and in the way locals speak about “what happened here long ago.”

This is your guide to the islands with more stories than people—and how to explore them without disturbing their delicate balance of myth and reality.

Why These Islands Are Different

While many islands have histories, these stand out because:

Population is tiny – Sometimes fewer than 50 residents, often seasonal or part-time.

Storytelling is woven into daily life – Myths aren’t just heritage; they’re part of local identity.

Legends shape the landscape – Every hill, cave, and cove has a name tied to a tale.

Isolation preserves tradition – With fewer visitors and little outside influence, oral histories remain intact.

The result? A place where your guide might be one of only a handful of residents—and where you might hear a story passed down through 10 generations while standing on the exact spot it happened.

Notable Islands Where Legends Outnumber Locals

St. Kilda, Scotland

Population: 0 permanent residents (seasonal staff & researchers)
Located 40 miles off the Outer Hebrides, St. Kilda was abandoned by its last inhabitants in 1930, but the island’s stories endure. From Viking raids to eerie accounts of “boat coffins” drifting to Norway, its isolation has bred a rich, sometimes dark folklore. Today, it’s a UNESCO World Heritage Site where puffins outnumber humans by thousands.

Travel Tip: Access is by boat tours from the Hebrides—weather permitting. The seas are famously rough, so pack seasickness remedies.

Chiloe Island, Chile

Population: ~160,000 (but spread out, rural, and fiercely traditional)
Chiloe is larger than most islands on this list, but it earns its place because of its dense web of myths. Stories of the ghost ship Caleuche, forest spirits, and shape-shifting sea creatures are told with conviction. Wooden churches built by Jesuits blend with indigenous traditions, making the island’s folklore uniquely hybrid.

Travel Tip: Visit in winter for moody fog and fewer tourists—perfect for hearing ghost stories in candlelit kitchens.

Fair Isle, Scotland

Population: ~60
This tiny speck between Orkney and Shetland is known for seabirds, knitwear, and Norse legends. Locals speak of selkies (seal-people) and shipwrecks, and the island’s remoteness has kept these tales alive. The landscape feels like it hasn’t changed in centuries, adding weight to every story told.

Travel Tip: Flights are small and weather-dependent—plan for delays, and bring something to read by the fire.

Yakushima, Japan

Population: ~13,000 (but 90% of the island is wild forest)
Though larger than some on this list, Yakushima feels otherworldly. Ancient cedar trees—some over 7,000 years old—have inspired myths of mountain spirits and forest guardians. The island famously influenced the Studio Ghibli film Princess Mononoke, adding a modern layer to its mythic aura.

Travel Tip: Trek to Jōmon Sugi, the most ancient cedar, and listen for the silence between the wind—it’s part of the magic.

Pitcairn Island, Pacific Ocean

Population: ~50
Settled by mutineers from the HMS Bounty and their Polynesian companions, Pitcairn is a remote island with a living history of secrecy, survival, and scandal. Stories of the mutiny, hidden coves, and self-sufficient life are still told by descendants of the original settlers.

Travel Tip: Getting here requires multiple boat transfers and careful planning—there’s no airport, and supply ships are rare.

Saba, Caribbean Netherlands

Population: ~1,900
Known as “The Unspoiled Queen,” Saba is small, steep, and shrouded in clouds. Stories of pirate treasure, shipwrecks, and hurricanes are part of its charm. With no real beaches, Saba has avoided mass tourism, keeping its cultural heritage strong.

Travel Tip: The island’s airport has one of the world’s shortest commercial runways—landing here is an adventure in itself.

Lundy, England

Population: ~28
Perched in the Bristol Channel, Lundy has tales of smugglers, pirates, and even a castle ruin. The island has been privately owned, traded for debt, and once had its own postage stamps and currency. Visitors often hear the legend of the “Devil’s Slide,” a sheer cliff tied to local lore.

Travel Tip: There’s no phone signal—perfect for disconnecting and letting the stories sink in.

Tristan da Cunha, South Atlantic

Population: ~250
The most remote inhabited island on Earth, Tristan has stories of volcanic eruptions, wartime evacuations, and shipwrecked sailors who decided to stay. Isolation means nearly everyone is related, and storytelling is both entertainment and cultural record.

Travel Tip: Supply ships arrive only a handful of times per year—travel here is a true commitment.

Inis Mór, Aran Islands, Ireland

Population: ~760
Inis Mór is famous for its stone forts, windswept cliffs, and Irish-language speakers who keep Celtic myths alive. Tales of banshees, fairy paths, and holy wells are told alongside real histories of famine and resilience.

Travel Tip: Rent a bike—roads are few, and pedaling between story sites adds to the experience.

Easter Island (Rapa Nui), Chile

Population: ~7,750
While more visited than others here, Easter Island is a living legend thanks to its iconic moai statues and the mystery of how they were moved. Stories of ancestral spirits, birdman competitions, and Polynesian navigation traditions still shape island culture today.

Travel Tip: Respect sacred sites—many are still actively used in cultural rituals.

How to Visit Without Disturbing the Story

When visiting islands where stories are the lifeblood, tourism can be both a blessing and a threat. Keep these principles in mind:

Listen more than you speak – Storytelling is a gift; don’t rush or interrupt.

Support local guides – They are often the storytellers preserving traditions.

Avoid overexposure – Don’t geotag fragile spots that can’t handle crowds.

Respect cultural boundaries – Some stories or places may be off-limits to outsiders.

Stay longer if you can – Trust takes time, and so does hearing the best tales.

Why These Islands Stay in Your Memory

You might forget the exact date of your visit or the name of the boat you arrived on, but the stories from these islands stay with you. They’re layered—part history, part myth, part personal anecdote from the person who told them.

And unlike a museum or a history book, these tales are alive. They shift slightly in the telling, carrying the voice of the person sharing them, shaped by their own experiences. That’s why on these islands with more stories than people, you’re not just learning about the past—you’re becoming part of the narrative’s living chain.

So next time you’re tempted to book a trip to a well-known beach destination, consider instead a place where you’ll return home not just with photos, but with a story you can’t wait to pass on.

Get In Touch